Former Yorkshire chairman Roger Hutton has criticized the England and Wales Cricket Boards’ “deeply disappointing” dealing with of the membership’s racism scandal.
However Hutton stated the method had been “dangerous” and questioned its independence.
The previous president stated he was appalled that the ECB’s personal conduct in the course of the affair had not been investigated.
The ECB declined to remark.
Final week, the governing physique stated it had accomplished what it known as a “thorough and sophisticated” investigation.
Particulars of racial abuse in Yorkshire first surfaced in September 2020, when former participant Azeem Rafiq stated discrimination made him really feel suicidal.
Yorkshire launched “a proper inquiry” in response, and a 12 months later an unbiased panel upheld seven of the 43 allegations made by Rafiq.
Nonetheless, the panel’s report was not printed and no participant, worker or supervisor was subjected to disciplinary motion on account of its findings.
The consequence sparked widespread criticism, and in November 2021, the ECB suspended Yorkshire from internet hosting worldwide matches at Headingley, “till it has clearly proven that it will probably meet the anticipated requirements”. Former chairman Hutton resigned, as did CEO Mark Arthur.
The ECB restored Yorkshire’s proper to host England’s check matches following authorities reforms and a employees overhaul. It then accomplished what it known as a “thorough and sophisticated” investigation to ascertain the rationale for the costs in opposition to each the county and the people concerned.
However Hutton – who was important of the ECB final 12 months when he testified earlier than a parliamentary committee, claiming they may have carried out extra to assist the county examine Rafiq’s allegations – says he discovered it “deeply disappointing” , that the governing physique didn’t “think about it acceptable to look at their conduct with the ECB”.
“You’ll do not forget that the ECB knew of Azeem’s claims earlier than I did. They did nothing about them,” he stated.
“They didn’t supply to assist the YCCC [Yorkshire] examine regardless of the apparent difficulties it confronted in doing so, and when the YCCC requested them to assist, they refused to take action. I believe this needs to be questioned.
“I additionally assume that the ECB’s examine itself has been poor.”
Hutton criticized the “lack of independence.”
“I’ve raised these considerations with the ECB and so they have dismissed them,” he stated.
“I’m satisfied that cricket can be higher served with a totally unbiased regulatory arm, so not solely would this guarantee a good and goal course of that everybody might belief it to be.”
The ECB performed its personal inquiry into the saga, however it was overseen by a regulatory committee that has an unbiased chair and contains a number of unbiased members.
The fees will likely be heard by an unbiased panel of the Cricket Disciplinary Fee.
The ECB has refused to call any accused individuals.
It’s understood that former English captain Michael Vaughan and former Yorkshire gamers Matthew Hoggard, Tim Bresnan and Andrew Gale are among the many accused.
BBC Sport has approached the individuals for a remark.
Former Yorkshire and England captain Vaughan revealed that he had been accused of creating racist feedback to Rafiq and different gamers, however has repeatedly denied the allegations.
Vaughan informed the BBC he by no means made racist feedback whereas within the county. He admitted to regretting some tweets he had despatched earlier.
The ECB has additionally been criticized by three different former Yorkshire chairmen – Colin Graves, Steve Denison and Robin Smith – who, together with Hutton, additionally informed the Telegraph about their considerations concerning the dealing with of the method.